Best Gay Friendly Hotels in Key West

We checked thousands of reviews on and to find the best hotels for your stay
Go to Hotel List View map

Nestled at the southernmost tip of the Florida Keys, Key West beckons with its laid-back charm and vibrant atmosphere. Known for its welcoming spirit and diverse community, this island paradise is a haven for LGBTQ+ travelers seeking a memorable getaway. With a plethora of gay friendly hotels in Key West, visitors can look forward to a stay that embraces inclusivity and celebrates individuality.

From boutique guesthouses to luxury resorts, Key West offers a range of accommodations that cater to the LGBTQ+ community. Whether you're looking for a romantic escape or a lively vacation, there is a gay friendly hotel in Key West to suit every taste and preference. With stunning ocean views, stylish design, and personalized service, these establishments provide a welcoming and safe space for all travelers, regardless of their sexual orientation.

Immerse yourself in the colorful and lively atmosphere of Key West, where art galleries, lively bars, and historic landmarks await. Explore the vibrant Duval Street or unwind on the sandy shores of Smathers Beach, knowing that a warm welcome awaits you back at your chosen gay friendly hotel. Indulge in the island's culinary delights, soak up the sun, and experience true relaxation in a destination that prides itself on diversity and inclusivity.

Show more + Show less -

Our Top 8

(Sorted by rating & number of reviews)

1. Sunset Key Cottages
2. The Reach Key West, Curio Collection By Hilton Hotel
3. Paradise Inn - Adult Exclusive
4. Ocean Key Resort & Spa, A Noble House Resort
5. Silver Palms Inn
6. The Marquesa Hotel
7. New Orleans House - Gay Male Adult Guesthouse
8. The Gardens Hotel

Luxurious Gay Friendly Hotels in Key West

Check Availability

Key West
Mar 23, 2026 - Mar 24, 2026

Sunset Key Cottages

9.2

Good

(108 Reviews)

+ 186 photos
Escape to the private oasis of Sunset Key Cottages, a luxurious island retreat accessible only by boat. Surrounded by crystal-clear waters and lush greenery, this exclusive resort offers impeccable service and upscale amenities. Embracing diversity and acceptance, Sunset Key Cottages is a sanctuary for LGBTQ+ travelers seeking a secluded and upscale experience in Key West.
Address: 245 Front St
Rating: Good 9.2 (108 Reviews)
Rooms: 40
Price: From 760$

The Reach Key West, Curio Collection By Hilton Hotel

7.1

Good

(336 Reviews)

+ 137 photos
Located on the shores of the Atlantic Ocean, The Reach Key West combines classic elegance with modern comforts in a stunning beachfront setting. The hotel's luxurious accommodations, beachfront pool, and attentive service create a serene escape for LGBTQ+ guests. Embracing diversity and acceptance, The Reach Key West invites travelers to experience the beauty of Key West in a welcoming and inclusive environment.
Address: 1435 Simonton Street
Rating: Good 7.1 (336 Reviews)
Rooms: 150
Price: From 275$

Quirky and Charming Gay Friendly Hotels in Key West

For travelers with a penchant for unique and eclectic accommodations, Key West boasts a range of quirky hotels that cater to LGBTQ+ guests. These charming establishments blend colorful decor, artistic flair, and a laid-back atmosphere, reflecting the island's vibrant spirit and inclusive ethos. From cozy guesthouses to boutique inns, each hotel in this selection offers a one-of-a-kind experience that celebrates individuality and creativity.

Paradise Inn - Adult Exclusive

8.5

Good

(695 Reviews)

+ 148 photos
Steeped in historic charm and tropical beauty, The Paradise Inn is a romantic oasis nestled in the center of Key West's Old Town. This boutique hotel features cozy cottages, lush gardens, and a tranquil pool, providing a secluded retreat for couples. With its warm and inviting atmosphere, The Paradise Inn welcomes LGBTQ+ guests with open arms, inviting them to immerse themselves in the romance and serenity of Key West.
Address: 819 Simonton Street
Rating: Good 8.5 (695 Reviews)
Rooms: 21
Price: From 434$

Ocean Key Resort & Spa, A Noble House Resort

8.4

Good

(126 Reviews)

+ 327 photos
Perched on the edge of Key West Harbor, Ocean Key Resort & Spa embodies luxury and romance in a breathtaking waterfront setting. The hotel's elegant accommodations, oceanfront balconies, and world-class spa facilities cater to couples looking for a blissful escape. Known for its inclusive environment and attentive staff, Ocean Key Resort & Spa offers a romantic haven for LGBTQ+ travelers seeking a memorable and enchanting experience.
Address: Zero Duval Street
Rating: Good 8.4 (126 Reviews)
Rooms: 100
Price: From 399$

Romantic Gay Friendly Hotels in Key West

For couples looking to ignite the spark or celebrate a special occasion, Key West offers a selection of romantic hotels that cater to LGBTQ+ travelers. These intimate and charming establishments provide a picturesque backdrop for a memorable getaway, complete with luxurious amenities and personalized service. From cozy bed and breakfasts to upscale retreats, each hotel in this category exudes romance and allows guests to create lasting memories in a welcoming and inclusive environment.

Silver Palms Inn

8.6

Good

(3345 Reviews)

+ 56 photos
Situated just steps from the historic seaport, Silver Palms Inn offers a comfortable and affordable stay in the very heart of Key West. The hotel's modern rooms, tropical courtyard, and complimentary breakfast cater to guests seeking a convenient and budget-friendly option. With a commitment to inclusivity and exceptional value, Silver Palms Inn provides a welcoming and relaxed atmosphere for LGBTQ+ travelers to enjoy a memorable stay in Key West.
Address: 830 Truman Avenue
Rating: Good 8.6 (3345 Reviews)
Rooms: 50
Price: From 143$

The Marquesa Hotel

9.5

Good

(83 Reviews)

+ 209 photos
Nestled in the very heart of Key West's historic district, The Marquesa Hotel exudes charm and sophistication. This boutique hotel boasts elegant accommodations, lush tropical gardens, and a tranquil ambiance perfect for relaxation. With a commitment to inclusivity and warm hospitality, The Marquesa Hotel ensures that all guests feel welcomed and valued during their stay.
Address: 600 Fleming Street
Rating: Good 9.5 (83 Reviews)
Rooms: 44
Price: From 440$

Budget-Friendly Gay Friendly Hotels in Key West

Travelers looking to explore Key West on a budget can make the most of their stay with these affordable and welcoming hotels tailored to LGBTQ+ guests. Combining value, comfort, and inclusivity, these accommodations offer a convenient base for exploring the island's attractions without breaking the bank. From quaint guesthouses to cozy inns, each hotel in this selection provides a budget-friendly option for LGBTQ+ travelers seeking a memorable and welcoming experience in Key West.

New Orleans House - Gay Male Adult Guesthouse

8.3

Good

(256 Reviews)

+ 90 photos
Located in the lively heart of Key West's Duval Street, New Orleans House offers budget-friendly accommodations in a lively and central location. This LGBTQ+-friendly guesthouse features cozy rooms, a clothing-optional pool, and a vibrant atmosphere perfect for socializing. Embracing diversity and affordability, New Orleans House provides a fun and inclusive environment for budget-conscious travelers looking to experience the best of Key West.
Address: 724 Duval Street
Rating: Good 8.3 (256 Reviews)
Rooms: 13
Price: From 217$

The Gardens Hotel

9.6

Good

(145 Reviews)

+ 158 photos
Step into a tropical paradise at The Gardens Hotel, a historic property adorned with lush gardens and charming cottages. Nestled in the very heart of Key West, this elegant hotel offers a tranquil retreat for LGBTQ+ travelers seeking a romantic getaway. With its enchanting ambiance and commitment to inclusivity, The Gardens Hotel provides a secluded and intimate setting for guests to relax and unwind.
Address: 526 Angela Street
Rating: Good 9.6 (145 Reviews)
Rooms: 22
Price: From 309$